1. Food

Your suggestion is on its way!

An email with a link to:


was emailed to:

Thanks for sharing About.com with others!

Readers Respond: Name Your Favorite and Non-Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

Responses: 432


Which is your favorite Girl Scout Cookie? Which is your least favorite? Are there ones that they don't make and you want back?

Complete List of Girl Scout Cookies

For the last couple of years I have been a big of the Samoas. I just love the coconut, caramel and chocolate combination. Thin Mints and Di-Si-Dos are my second and thirds. I will admit I am not a fan of the Tagalongs. I prefer a peanut butter filling that is gritty, like a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, as opposed to a smooth one. As far as missing any cookies, I miss the Thanks-A-Lot cookies. They no longer sell them in my area.

girl scout cookies

I really,really like the double dutch chocolate chip,the short bread,tha coconut macaroons.
—Guest latrice caston

thanks a lots

My favorite. Not available inn my area but found away to get some. lOVE THEM .:) :)
—Guest ronda


I miss the Juliet's bring them back please and the lemon suger free ones no other kinds compare to those
—Guest Belinda

Bring Back the Vanchos!

I sold them as a little girl. They were the best chocolate and vanilla sandwich cookies ever. Even better than Oreos. I also loved the chocolate chip cookies with the layer of chocolate along the bottom. But definitely Vanchos!
—Guest Winner

Bring back Cafe cookies

I dont like any of the new ones much but our whole family (large) always loved the cafe cookies. We dont buy any of the new ones. Its a shame they do away with the old time favorites.
—Guest grace


Shortbreads!!!!!! They're so good. One time I got a box of them and I ate ALL OF THEM in 1 day!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
—Guest guest Nicky

I want theses cookies back plz

Lemon coolers!!!!!!! Why have they gone..... They were the best wish y'all can bring them back I would buy like five boxes or more for my family and friends
—Guest joy

my favorite non existing girl scout cook

lemon coolers, was the best loved them :-( samosas are great, lemon pastry cream are ok , I just miss the past girl Scout cookies
—Guest desi from TX


I love Samoas. It is my favorite.yummy in my tummy
—Guest Jennifer


My favorite is the Thank u Berry Crunch..the best Cookie ever made
—Guest Erica


Thin mints r a must have!!! Always get extra to freeze. This yr I tried the Savannah smiles & wish I'd gotten more then one box. Never know when the girls will b out selling them to plan ahead...
—Guest irishLassie


Lemon pastry creams, scot-teas that are no longer avail. And tho the thin mints are still my favorite I liked them better when the cookie wasnt chocolate I lijed them better
—Guest Matt

Favorite GS cookie

Thanks a lot!!! I am devastated they're not offered in all areas...I've missed them the last two years!!!
—Guest Erica

Rating Cookies

Best to worst : Tagalongs, Dulce de leche, sugar free chocolate chip, thin mints, thank u BERRY MUNCH, Savannah Smiles, Do-si-dos, lemonades, lemon-chalet cremes, double dutch, Shortbread/Trefoils, Samoas, thanks-a-lots. The other cinnamon and coffee cookies werent very good in my opinion
—Guest cookies

Double Dutch

My family loved the Double Dutch and would make desert's with them and milk dipping nightly.
—Guest Mitch

©2015 About.com. All rights reserved.