1. Food
Send to a Friend via Email
You can opt-out at any time. Please refer to our privacy policy for contact information.

Readers Respond: Name Your Favorite and Non-Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

Responses: 632

By

Cookies

My favorite is thin mints and my least favorite is carmel delites
—Guest Bobby

Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

Love the Samoas. However, would like to see one of the cinnamon style cookies come back, as well as some 90 Calorie style packs.
—Guest Janet Smith

sugar free chocolate chips

I loved the sugar free chocolate chips. I don't know why I don't see them anymore. What are you offering diabetics?
—Guest willa

Miss, miss, miss!

I miss the old thin mint cookies...the cookie was vanilla, not chocolate. I also miss the sandwich cookies.
—Guest Madcow

What I Miss

I loved Lemon Pastry Cremes and the original shortbread cookies with the sugar crystals on top, and I liked the animal treasures. Samoas are way too sweet!
—Guest Lori

ms tina

Mid west had Scot teas... Short bread with a light sugar sprinkle on top... I used to love those cookies and had my family in Ohio send me a boxes each yr. Recently years.. I have heard you have x' d those cookies. Trefoils are so boring and we luv the chocolate chip.. but can't find.. stop limiting our cookies.. plz.. thx
—Guest tina

Favorite Cookies

Lemon Pastry Cream because last year was my first time taking them and I fell in love with them. Please bring them back.
—Guest LadiSeahorse

Lemon Cookie

I miss the Lemon Chalet cookies. These are and will allways be my favorite. I've noticed that lemon cookies have been changed to a different lemon flavor, in the past years. This year I bought the lemon coolers, but did not like. Please bring back, the lemon chalet.
—Guest Laura

Lemon Cookie

I miss the Lemon Chalet cookies. These are and always be my favorite. I've noticed that lemon cookies have been changed to a different lemon flavor. This year I bought the lemon coolers, but did not like. Please bring back, the lemon chalet.
—Guest Laura

Samoas...delish!

I hate when I can't eat them because I'm on a diet! The original name (Samoas) is not offensive to my hawaiian friends. This country is just to politically correct! They should've left the name alone!
—CaliAquaGirl

scot teas

I would lov e to have one of them with a hot cup of tea.
—Guest guest

I Wish I Had....

I would like to see the Ice-Berry Pinatas return! They were the best cookie. I also liked the Lemon Pastry Cremes! Please give them one more chance, they sure beat those Mango numbers!
—Guest Fran Crespo

praline royals

Ooh please bring back the praline royals. I sold these when I was a girl scout, they were the best. There has not been another cookie that has come close.
—Guest guest amber

Lemon Pastry Creams

I miss the Lemon Pastry Creams the new lemon cookies just don't taste as good. PLEASE bring them back
—Guest Cheryl

Very Disappointed

Don't know what changed this year but I am disappointed. The Thin Mints don't taste as minty, the Tagalongs are as thin as the Thin Mints and the peanut butter cookies have barely any filling. I don't mind paying the price to support the girls but do expect to get my money's worth.
—Guest Kelly

Share Your Favorite

Name Your Favorite and Non-Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.