1. Food & Drink

Discuss in my forum

Readers Respond: Name Your Favorite and Non-Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

Responses: 432

By , About.com Guide

?????

Seen only one kind here in Canada. No flavour & texture of cardboard.
—Guest janice

bring back the cookies!!!

coconut and lemon coolers please bring them back. I was surprised that the coconut ones got discontinued this year.
—Guest marie53

Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

I love the Lemon Pastry Creme & Thanks A Lot Cokkies. Both have been retired in my area & I wish they were back.
—Guest Mary C.

I miss..

Lemon pastry cremes. I only had them once and after that they were gone. My faves are shortbread and now dulce de leche. My least fave would be Tagalongs. It's something about the peanut butter in it.
—Guest Tea

jana

Sold cookies myself 35+yrs ago some cookies have changed names its confusing. I always order peanut butter sandwish and patties along with shortbread and thin mints. I miss lemon sandwich and thanks a lot aka all around. Please bring back to western oklahoma
—Guest jana

jana

I miss lemon sandwich and thanks a lot aka all arounds Please bring back to western oklahoma
—Guest jana

Bring back Cafe cookies

My favorite girl scout cookies are defintely tagalongs. My least favorite is the trefoils because they are too plain for me, its like eating animal crackers. My other favorite cookie was the cafe cookies. I didn't think I would like them the first time I tried one but it ended up being one of my favorites and I wish they would come back. The all abouts were good too
—Guest Colleen

Favorite girl scout cookies

My favorite Girl Scout Cookie is the Thanks-a-lot or Thin Mints or Do-si-dos
—Guest sky

My favorite girl scouts cookie

Tagalongs is my FAVORITE cookie because of the yummy chocolate and peanut butter! I LOVE them soo much and i wait for girl scout cookies to be on sale year-round... Because once my family gets them, their gone ): i think the cookies should be sold all year! (; 365
—Guest Savanah

non favorite gs cookie

my non fav cookie is the coconut and my fav is the dulce de leche
—Guest momomomoomom

New favorite - lemonades

I got my first taste of lemonades this year from a scout from Texas. They went over big with all of us in the office. When will we get them in Memphis?
—Guest Pauletta

carmel D'S

As my friends and I sit here in Iraq we have found ourselves once again thinking of home and what we miss. Without a doubt it is the carmel delites, the king of the girl scout cookies.
—Guest kevin

Bring Lemon Coolers Back!

I only found these one year and I am still talking about them. My favorite!
—Guest Louise

love em

my number one favorite cookies are thin mints! i cannot live without them if they EVER stop selling them i would go crazy. i also like tagalongs but they are such a rip pf it 3.50 for 15 cookies in florida- talk about a rip off
—Guest kk

Scout mom

I really love and miss the sugar free chocolate chip cookie. Please bring this one back, everyone still asks for them!
—Guest Sophie

Share Your Favorite

Name Your Favorite and Non-Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.